Are Hidden Assets Hiding Beneath Your Basement?

Real Estate for the Perplexed
By Dennis H. Goodhart, with Hymie, my AI collaborator

Groundbreaking commercial building news for property owners considering geothermal.

Heating and cooling may not be the most exciting part of owning real estate—until the system breaks or the utility bill arrives.

Geothermal heating and cooling has been around for decades. So why should a commercial property owner take another look now? Because geothermal is no longer simply an environmental discussion. Depending on the property, available incentives, utility costs and financing, it can become a real estate investment decision.

The question is not simply whether geothermal can lower energy consumption. What will it cost after incentives, how much can the owner save or recover, and how long before the investment pays back?

First, How Does It Work?

Geothermal—more accurately called a Ground-Source Heat Pump—uses the relatively steady temperature below ground to help heat a building in winter and cool it in summer.

A buried loop acts as the heat exchanger. In summer, the system transfers heat from the building into the ground. In winter, it pulls heat from the ground and moves it into the building through an indoor heat pump. Some systems can also help provide hot water. You don’t need a volcano under the parking lot. The advantage is that the system is exchanging heat with relatively stable underground temperatures rather than extremely hot or cold outside air.

Why Give It Another Look Now?

Part of the answer is regulation. New York has adopted all-electric building requirements intended to restrict fossil-fuel equipment in most new construction, although implementation has been affected by ongoing litigation. Existing property owners are not generally being ordered to tear out functioning gas or oil systems, and anyone planning a project should confirm the requirements actually in effect when permits are filed.

But regulations are only part of the story. Geothermal systems can offer high operating efficiency, relatively low maintenance, quieter operation and long equipment life. The commercial geothermal presentation that prompted this article cites potential heating-cost reductions of 30% to 70% and cooling-cost reductions of 20% to 50%, although actual results will vary significantly by building, utility rates and system design.

The U.S. Department of Energy estimates geothermal indoor components can last up to approximately 24 years, while the underground loop may last 50 years or more. That makes the analysis different from simply comparing the price of two pieces of HVAC equipment.

Incentives Can Change the Math

The upfront cost of geothermal is usually the objection property owners hear first. That is a legitimate concern. Drilling, underground loops, engineering and installation can make the initial price considerably higher than a conventional replacement. But the sticker price is not necessarily the owner’s final cost.

For commercial geothermal projects, the federal Investment Tax Credit currently provides a 6% base credit for qualifying installations through 2032, with the potential for substantially larger credits—up to 30% in qualifying circumstances—when applicable requirements are met. The rules are technical enough that eligibility should be confirmed with a qualified tax adviser before being incorporated into an investment decision.

New York property owners may also have utility incentives available. Con Edison currently offers geothermal incentives for commercial and multifamily projects, with amounts varying according to building type and project design. NYSERDA also offers technical-assistance programs that can help businesses evaluate heating, cooling and electrification opportunities before committing capital.

Local government can matter as well. New York’s C-PACE program allows participating municipalities to make long-term financing available for qualifying commercial energy improvements, including geothermal. That is financing rather than a rebate, but spreading project costs over a longer term can materially change the cash-flow calculation. Towns in Westchester County are among the municipalities participating in the statewide program.

So before rejecting geothermal because of the initial installation price, an owner should first ask:

• What incentives does this particular project qualify for?
• What would the conventional system cost anyway?
• What are the projected annual operating and maintenance savings?
• How long will each system last?
• Can the remaining cost be financed over a period that matches the useful life of the improvement?

A Sample Business Case

Consider a hypothetical multi-tenant commercial building whose HVAC system is approaching replacement. Suppose a conventional replacement would cost $350,000, while a geothermal system would cost $700,000 before incentives.

For illustration, assume the geothermal project qualifies for a 30% federal credit and receives another $50,000 in utility or other project incentives. The $50,000 figure is purely hypothetical; actual incentives would have to be determined for the specific property.

Illustrative Business Case Amount
Gross geothermal installation $700,000
Illustrative 30% federal credit ($210,000)
Illustrative additional incentives ($50,000)
Net geothermal investment $440,000
Cost of conventional HVAC replacement $350,000
Additional investment in geothermal $90,000
Estimated annual energy/maintenance savings $18,000
Simple payback on additional investment 5 years

Now look at the additional $90,000 investment over five years:

Year Cumulative Illustrative Savings Unrecovered Additional Investment
Initial investment $0 $90,000
1 $18,000 $72,000
2 $36,000 $54,000
3 $54,000 $36,000
4 $72,000 $18,000
5 $90,000 $0

That is not a projection for any particular building. Change the incentive, installation cost, utility rate or operating savings and the answer changes immediately.

DOE consumer guidance has estimated that the additional cost of geothermal can sometimes be recovered through energy savings in approximately 5 to 10 years, while other DOE comparisons with air-source heat pumps have cited 10 to 15 years. Commercial buildings require their own engineering and financial analysis, but a roughly 5-to-15-year range is useful as an initial screening concept rather than a promise.

Who Gets the Savings?

For a multi-tenant property, there is another question that should interest the owner: Who receives the financial benefit?

If tenants currently pay their own utilities, simply reducing their energy bills does not automatically repay the landlord for installing geothermal. That does not mean the investment cannot work. It means the lease structure becomes part of the business case.

Depending on the building, leases and applicable utility rules, future tenants might continue paying their individual electricity usage while benefiting from a central geothermal infrastructure system. Ownership might capture part of the additional value through higher rent, operating-expense recovery, HVAC charges or properly structured metered energy arrangements. Alternatively, an owner could include some utilities in rent and retain the savings—but then ownership also assumes the risk if energy consumption rises. This is why geothermal should not be evaluated only by an HVAC contractor.

For an income-producing property, the analysis should include engineering, financing, incentives, leases and real estate economics. If an owner could capture $18,000 of recurring annual savings as additional net operating income, for example, that income could also affect the property’s value. At a purely illustrative 6.5% capitalization rate, $18,000 of additional NOI equates to approximately $277,000 in indicated value. That is not an appraisal. It simply demonstrates why a building-system decision can become a real estate investment decision.

What Is on the Horizon?

There is another development worth watching. Geothermal may not always be a one-building-at-a-time decision.

Thermal energy networks can connect multiple buildings through shared piping, geothermal borefields, wastewater heat or other thermal sources. Instead of every building owning a completely independent heating and cooling source, several properties may someday be able to share part of the infrastructure.

New York utilities are already exploring thermal-network projects, which suggests the future question for some owners may eventually change from “Should I install geothermal?” to “Can my property connect to a shared thermal-energy system?”

That will not happen everywhere, and probably not tomorrow. But for developers, municipalities and owners planning buildings that may remain in service for another 30, 40 or 50 years, it is worth following.

The Bottom Line

Geothermal is not right for every property. Site conditions matter. Drilling can be expensive. Electrical capacity, available land, existing HVAC distribution, building usage and local utility rates all affect the answer. Tax credits and incentives also change over time. But if you are developing a new building, planning a substantial renovation, or approaching replacement of an aging HVAC system, geothermal deserves to be included in the analysis.

Don’t ask only: “What does geothermal cost?”

Ask: “What does the alternative cost, what incentives are available, what will each system cost to operate over its useful life, and who gets the savings?”

The ground beneath your property may be doing more than holding up the building.

DHG Realty Group can help you evaluate whether geothermal is the right move for your property and help bring together the real estate, financial and professional resources needed to determine whether the opportunity warrants a closer look.

Sources

U.S. Department of Energy, geothermal heat-pump guidance, commercial tax-credit information, equipment-life estimates and consumer payback guidance.

NYSERDA, commercial heating, cooling, technical-assistance and C-PACE financing resources.

Con Edison, current geothermal incentives for commercial and multifamily properties.

Billii Roberti, Green Choices Consulting, Geothermal Heat Pumps for Commercial Realtors. The presentation supplied background information and commercial examples used in researching this article.

Disclaimer: This article is for general informational purposes only. It is not engineering, legal, tax, accounting or investment advice. Incentives, tax credits, financing, utility rates, installation costs, lease provisions and projected savings are property- and project-specific and should be independently verified with the appropriate professionals before making an investment decision.

Disclosure: The opinions expressed are those of the author. Dennis H. Goodhart is Principal of DHG Realty Group LLC and a licensed Associate Real Estate Broker with eXp Realty. Except for those disclosed relationships, the author is not employed by, compensated by, sponsored by, or affiliated with any of the companies, organizations, products or services mentioned in this article. The author does have a paid ChatGPT subscription. ChatGPT, referred to here as “Hymie,” is credited as an AI writing collaborator.

Real Estate for the Perplexed is written by Dennis H. Goodhart with assistance from Hymie, his AI collaborator. Dennis retains editorial responsibility for the published content.